Crothersville Real Estate

Crothersville Real Estate

Welcome to Crothersville, Indiana – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Jackson County. With a population of just over 1,600 residents, this quaint town offers the perfect blend of small-town charm and modern convenience. Established in the mid-19th century, Crothersville boasts a rich history that is reflected in its beautifully preserved architecture and friendly community spirit.

One of the town's standout features is its commitment to community events, making it a vibrant place to live and thrive. From the annual Crothersville Red, White, and Blue Festival, which celebrates the town's patriotic spirit with parades, live music, and delicious local food, to farmers' markets that showcase the region's agricultural bounty, there’s always something happening in Crothersville.

Nature enthusiasts will appreciate the town’s proximity to stunning parks and recreational areas. The nearby Muscatatuck National Wildlife Refuge offers opportunities for hiking, bird watching, and enjoying the great outdoors. With a variety of local shops, restaurants, and family-owned businesses, residents can enjoy a laid-back lifestyle while still having access to essential amenities.

Education is a cornerstone of the community with Crothersville Community Schools providing quality education and fostering a sense of belonging for students and families alike.

Whether you’re searching for a cozy home or an investment opportunity, Crothersville presents an inviting and affordable real estate market. Experience the warmth of this charming Indiana town where community, nature, and history come together to create a truly unique living experience. Come discover why Crothersville is not just a place to live, but a place to call home!

Newest Listings in Crothersville

OPPORTUNITY AWAITS in the heart of Crothersville! Located at 100 N Armstrong Street, this .20-acre CORNER LOT sits at the ONLY STOPLIGHT IN TOWN, offering excellent visibility and a prime location for your next venture! Zoned COMMERCIAL and positioned right in the center of town, the possibilities here are exciting. Whether you’re an investor, entrepreneur, or developer looking for your next project, this could be the opportunity you’ve been waiting for. Help us help CROTHERSVILLE GROW! Offered at only $64,900 — bring your ideas and come DEVELOP this lot! Buyer to verify zoning, permitted uses, utilities, and any requirements applicable to their intended development.

100 N Armstrong Street, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Kovener & Associates Real Esta.

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 2026011627 MLS

Charming and AFFORDABLE home located at 303 Park Avenue in Crothersville! This 2-bedroom, 1-bath property offers spacious rooms and a comfortable layout that would make an excellent starter home or a great option for those looking to downsize. The home features a covered/enclosed front porch, perfect for relaxing, as well as a back deck for enjoying outdoor space. A full unfinished basement provides additional storage or potential for future use. The property also includes a storage shed for added convenience. Don’t miss this opportunity to own a well-maintained home at an attractive price point.

303 N Park Avenue, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Kovener & Associates Real Esta.

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 2026011425 MLS

Step back in time while enjoying modern updates in this charming historic brick home!** Featuring beautiful original woodwork, tall ceilings, classic architectural details, and stunning built-in cabinetry, this property is filled with character. Updated luxury vinyl plank flooring provides a fresh, durable touch while preserving the home's timeless appeal. The spacious rooms, abundant natural light, original doors and trim, and impressive brick exterior make this a truly distinctive property. A great opportunity for anyone looking for historic charm and craftsmanship with room to add their own personal touches. **Come see the character and possibilities this unique home has to offer!

300 W Howard Street, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of KGF Realty, LLC.

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 2026010361 MLS

Opportunity awaits with this 3 bed, 1 bath home offering a functional layout & key updates already in place. The living space flows into the kitchen & dining area, creating a practical setup for everyday living. Durable LVP flooring runs through main areas, & the kitchen features a brand new microwave & dishwasher—with all kitchen appliances included. A new HVAC with warranty & water heater adds additional peace of mind. Step outside to enjoy the privacy-fenced backyard—perfect for pets, outdoor gatherings, or relaxing evenings at home. 2 storage sheds provide extra space for tools & lawn equipment, while the garage offers added convenience. The front yard is shaded by mature shade trees, adding curb appeal & a welcoming feel. Low utilities, low taxes. Conveniently located with access to local amenities, this home offers both value and potential.

205 West Street, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX FIRST.

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 2026011183 MLS

Welcome to 100 N Bethany Road in Crothersville! Owned by the same family for its entire life, this well-built and solid home has been thoughtfully cared for through the years. Offering 3 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, the home features an attached garage, gas furnace, gas fireplace, and gas cooking stove. Outside, you’ll find a solid-surface driveway, carport, covered front porch, and three additional outbuildings providing plenty of space for storage, hobbies, tools, or a workshop. Situated on a corner lot, this property offers plenty of space, functionality, and opportunity for its next owner to make it their own!

100 N Bethany Road, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Kovener & Associates Real Esta.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026010742 MLS

Welcome home to this stunning NEW CONSTRUCTION in the heart of Crothersville! From the moment you pull into the driveway, you’ll notice the exceptional attention to detail and quality craftsmanship that sets this home apart. Built with care—not shortcuts—this home showcases thoughtful design, beautiful finishes, and superior workmanship throughout. Inside, you’ll find a unique and functional floor plan offering 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, a dedicated mechanical room, pantry, and utility room—features not often found in homes of this size. The spacious open-concept living area is highlighted by vaulted ceilings with a striking wood beam, creating a warm yet modern atmosphere that’s perfect for everyday living and entertaining. The beautifully designed kitchen flows seamlessly into the living and dining areas, while the private primary suite offers a true retreat with a walk-in closet, walk-in tiled shower, and double vanity with quartz countertops. Step outside to enjoy the covered front porch or relax on the rear patio, providing great spaces to unwind or entertain guests. This home is the perfect combination of quality, style, and functionality. Schedule your private showing today and be prepared to fall in love!

403 W Howard Street, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Kovener & Associates Real Esta.

6.82 acre tract that could be rezoned for residential or possible commercial. Public utilities available. Conveniently located to interstate. Additional 2 acre and 2+ acre parcels, ask for details.

400 S Block Armstrong Street, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Jack Bridgewater Real Estate.

2.173 acre tract that could be rezoned for residential or possible commercial. Public utilities available. Conveniently located to interstate. Additional 2 acre and 6+ acre parcels, ask for details.

6000 S Block Us Hwy 31, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Jack Bridgewater Real Estate.

2 acre tract that could be rezoned for residential or possible commercial. Public utilities available. Conveniently located to interstate. Additional 2+ acre and 6+ acre parcels, ask for more details.

6000 S Block Us Hwy 31, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Jack Bridgewater Real Estate.

8 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 202609608 MLS

Investment opportunity! 2 separate Duplexes, total of 4 units. Each unit is 2 Bedroom, 1 Bath. Units currently rent at $700 and tenants pay all utilities. 3 units are currently rented, 1 unit is unoccupied. Call/text today to schedule a showing!

202-204 Myres Street, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Bridge Realtors.

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 202609372 MLS

Cozy and Convenient. 2 bedroom 1 bath with bonus room that could be used as 3rd bedroom or family area. Attached garage with large fenced in yard. Property sold As Is

204 E Bard Street, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Jack Bridgewater Real Estate.

Check out this 2.73 +/- acres in Marion township. Great road frontage. Call for more info today! Sold As-Is.

S County Road 910 W, Crothersville

Listing courtesy of Lopp Real Estate Brokers.

Start Your Search

Kara Whalin

I’ve been serving Kentuckiana as a real estate consultant for over 8 years. After 20 years of medical and veterinary sales, I wanted to use my skills and experience to help people meet their real estate goals. Whether you’re looking to put down roots in a nearby neighborhood, are just starting out, want to invest in the local community, or are ready to downsize, I can help you navigate the market on both sides of the river.But my job is so much more than just buying and selling real estate. I’m the one who’ll be saving you a seat at the ballgame and am always available to move a couch. I know who to call when your AC goes out in July and am the reason your grandma’s house sold in a weekend. I’ll be the first to celebrate your big wins, the last to leave the closing table, and the one who turns house hunting into an adventure.After all, it’s more than just a house! It’s where you build your life, your business, your community; and there is nothing more special to me than being invited to go along for the ride. So, let’s grab a coffee, chat about your goals, and start turning your dreams into an address. Whether you’re just curious or ready to make a move, I’m here to answer your questions and make it happen!

Learn More